What Is a PML? SEL and SUL Explained for CRE Lenders
PML, SEL and SUL in plain terms: what each earthquake loss measure means, how lenders use them, and what drives the number up or down.
“Get a PML” is still how most loan teams ask for an earthquake study. The number that comes back is usually not called a PML anymore, though. Here is what the terms mean and why the difference matters.
Where “PML” came from
PML (probable maximum loss) started as an insurance term: an estimate of how much of a building’s value an earthquake could destroy, expressed as a percentage of replacement cost. The problem was that “probable” and “maximum” meant different things to different people. One report might use a 475-year earthquake and an average loss, another a rarer earthquake and an upper-bound loss, and both would call the result a PML.
ASTM standardized the vocabulary. ASTM E2026 (the guide for seismic risk assessment of buildings) and ASTM E2557 (the practice for PML evaluations in earthquake due diligence) define specific loss measures, so a lender in New York and an engineer in California mean the same thing.
SEL and SUL
The two measures you will see most often in a due diligence report:
| Term | What it means |
|---|---|
| SEL, scenario expected loss | The average (mean) expected repair cost for a defined earthquake scenario, as a percentage of the building’s replacement cost. |
| SUL, scenario upper loss | The loss for the same scenario at the 90th percentile: the level the loss is unlikely to exceed. |
In due diligence work the scenario is commonly the ground motion with a 10% chance of being exceeded in 50 years, often called the 475-year earthquake. So an “SEL of 12%” reads as: in the shaking expected about once every 475 years, the average expected repair cost is about 12% of what it would cost to rebuild.
What number is acceptable?
That is the lender’s call, not the engineer’s. Many lenders and loan programs use an SEL threshold, often around 20%, above which they require earthquake insurance, a retrofit or other conditions. Some also look at SUL. Your lender’s guidelines govern; the assessment’s job is to give an accurate, well-supported number.
What moves the estimate
The loss estimate is driven by two things: how hard the ground is likely to shake at the site, and how this particular building responds to that shaking.
- Location and soils. Distance to active faults matters, and so do soft soils, bay mud, fill and liquefiable sands, which can amplify shaking or fail outright.
- Structural system and era. Unreinforced masonry, non-ductile concrete, older tilt-ups and soft-story wood buildings generally carry higher losses than modern steel, concrete or wood buildings designed to recent codes.
- Irregularities. Soft or weak first stories, torsion from off-center walls, re-entrant corners and discontinuous walls or frames concentrate damage.
- Condition and alterations. Deterioration, corrosion and undocumented alterations can weaken the load path.
- Retrofits. A completed, permitted retrofit can bring the estimate down substantially, but only if it’s verified.
Why the site visit matters
Most of the inputs above can’t be confirmed from a desk. A drawing set might show a seismic upgrade that was never built, or miss a later alteration that opened up a shear wall. The site visit, done by someone who understands how buildings resist earthquakes, is what makes the number trustworthy.
If you have a Northern California property that needs an SEL/SUL estimate, send me the details.