ASTM E2026 vs. E2557: How the Two Seismic Standards Fit Together
ASTM E2026 is the guide; E2557 is the due diligence practice. How the two seismic risk standards differ, and what that means for your scope.
Seismic risk assessment scopes usually cite two ASTM standards, often in the same sentence. They are related but not interchangeable, and knowing which does what makes it easier to order the right scope.
ASTM E2026: the guide
ASTM E2026, Standard Guide for Seismic Risk Assessment of Buildings, is the broad framework. It:
- defines the vocabulary, including loss measures such as SEL (scenario expected loss) and SUL (scenario upper loss);
- separates the assessment into parts: site stability (faulting, liquefaction, landslides), building stability (could it collapse?) and building damageability (how much damage, as a loss estimate);
- sets out levels of investigation, from a review of available information up to detailed engineering analysis, with more document review, site observation and calculation at each step;
- describes the qualifications of the people involved, including the assessor who visits the site and the senior assessor who is responsible for the conclusions.
As a guide, E2026 describes options rather than one required procedure. That makes it flexible enough for anything from a quick portfolio screen to a detailed study of a single building.
ASTM E2557: the due diligence practice
ASTM E2557, Standard Practice for Probable Maximum Loss (PML) Evaluations for Earthquake Due-Diligence Assessments, is narrower and more prescriptive. It sets the minimum scope for the earthquake study that typically goes along with a commercial real estate transaction or loan: document review, a site visit, and a damageability estimate that uses the E2026 terms and loss measures.
In practice, E2557 is the “standard order” for a lender’s PML, and E2026 supplies the definitions and the higher levels of investigation when a property needs more than the standard.
Side by side
| ASTM E2026 | ASTM E2557 | |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Guide | Practice |
| Purpose | Framework for seismic risk assessment of buildings | Minimum scope for due diligence PML evaluations |
| Flexibility | Several levels of investigation | A defined baseline scope |
| Typical use | Definitions, higher-level studies, portfolio work | Most CRE loan and acquisition PML reports |
What this means when you order a study
- Start from the lender’s or firm’s scope letter. It should name the standard, the level of investigation and the loss measures required. If it just says “PML,” ask.
- Match the level to the risk. A modern tilt-up in Sacramento and a 1920s concrete building near the Hayward fault rarely need the same depth.
- Expect the site visit. Both standards rely on observing the building. The quality of the field work drives the quality of the estimate.
- Know who signs. The senior assessor is responsible for the conclusions. Ask about their qualifications and experience with the building type.
I work as a Field Assessor and as a Senior Assessor on E2026 and E2557 assignments in Northern California. If a scope isn’t clear, I’m glad to talk it through before the site visit. Get in touch.