What a Seismic Field Assessor Checks on Site
A structural engineer’s walk-through of a seismic risk assessment site visit: documents, load path, irregularities, condition and site hazards.
The site visit is where a seismic risk assessment is won or lost. The senior assessor’s loss estimate can only be as good as the information gathered on site. Here is what I look for, and what property managers can do to help.
Before the visit
The most productive site visits start at the desk. I ask for, and review when available:
- Structural drawings, original and any later alterations, which show the lateral system and the design code era;
- Permits and retrofit records, especially for soft-story, tilt-up and masonry upgrades;
- Prior reports: earlier seismic studies, property condition assessments, geotechnical reports;
- Basic facts: year built, area, number of stories, occupancy, and recent damage or repairs.
Missing drawings are common and don’t stop an assessment, but they change what I need to see in the field.
On site: the structure
Identify the lateral system. Wood shear walls, concrete or masonry walls, braced frames or moment frames: what resists earthquake forces, and does it match the drawings?
Follow the load path. Earthquake forces travel from the roof and floors (diaphragms) into walls or frames, then down to the foundation. Weak links are where damage concentrates:
- roof-to-wall anchorage and continuity ties in concrete tilt-ups;
- open fronts and tuck-under parking that create soft or weak first stories;
- walls or frames that stop at one level and don’t continue to the foundation;
- cripple walls and sill anchorage in older wood buildings;
- welded steel moment connections in pre-1994 frames.
Look for irregularities. Off-center stiff elements (torsion), re-entrant corners, setbacks and large openings in diaphragms all change how a building responds.
Check condition. Cracking, corrosion, water damage, rot, settlement and past damage can weaken an otherwise adequate system, and so can undocumented alterations, such as a shear wall that was opened for a storefront.
On site: everything else that affects the estimate
- Falling hazards: unbraced parapets, heavy cladding, chimneys and ornamentation.
- Pounding: adjacent buildings close enough to collide.
- Site conditions: slopes, retaining walls, signs of settlement, and indicators of soft or liquefiable soils.
- Retrofits: anything the documents say was strengthened, verified in the field.
What a good field package looks like
For a due diligence firm, the deliverable is usually field notes, a photo log and completed forms in the firm’s own template. Good field packages share a few traits: every observation that affects the estimate is photographed and located, uncertainties are called out rather than guessed, and the notes connect what was seen to why it matters.
How property managers can help
- Provide roof, attic, basement and crawlspace access, plus mechanical and electrical rooms.
- Share drawings and retrofit records before the visit, even partial sets.
- Have someone on site who knows the building’s history: repairs, alterations and tenant improvements.
If you need a Northern California field assessor who looks at buildings like an engineer, let’s talk.